Why Are Nordstrom and Macy’s Ditching the Retail Inventory Method?

December 16, 2024

In a significant shift within the retail industry, major U.S. retailers Nordstrom and Macy’s have decided to abandon the century-old retail inventory method (RIM) in favor of cost accounting. This strategic move marks a pivotal change in how these companies manage and report their inventory, reflecting broader trends and technological advancements in the retail sector. The retail inventory method, developed in the 1920s, has long been a staple in the industry due to its simplicity and ease of implementation. However, as the retail landscape evolves, the limitations and outdated nature of RIM have become increasingly apparent. This article delves into the reasons behind this shift, the benefits of cost accounting, and the implications for the retail industry.

Limitations of the Retail Inventory Method

The retail inventory method (RIM) has been a widely used practice among U.S. retailers for nearly a century. However, its reliance on retail prices to estimate inventory rather than actual costs has led to several significant limitations. One of the primary issues with RIM is that it can create a distorted view of business metrics. By basing inventory valuations on retail prices, RIM introduces inconsistencies, especially when prices fluctuate due to markdowns and promotions. This method’s reliance on retail pricing introduces unreliability in financial reporting, which can mislead stakeholders about the true health of the business.

Another critical limitation of RIM is its susceptibility to manipulation. Retailers can ‘game’ the system by adjusting markdowns and promotions to influence inventory valuations. This practice can lead to misleading financial reports and poor decision-making by making the inventory appear artificially high or low, depending on the desired outcome. Additionally, RIM does not leverage modern technologies such as barcodes and computerized systems, making it less efficient and accurate in today’s digital age. The failure to incorporate contemporary technology contributes to inaccurate inventory counts and misalignment with current data management practices. Despite these flaws, RIM has remained popular due to its simplicity and ease of use, providing a quick approximation of inventory without the need for frequent manual counts. However, as the retail industry becomes more data-driven, the need for more precise and reliable inventory management methods has become increasingly evident.

The Superiority of Cost Accounting

In contrast to RIM, cost accounting offers a more accurate and stable method for inventory valuation. Cost accounting is based on the actual cost paid for inventory, providing a consistent measure that is unaffected by retail price changes. This method aligns well with modern data systems, offering greater accuracy and a clearer overall picture of inventory and margins. One of the key advantages of cost accounting is its ability to provide stable inventory values, which is essential for making informed strategic decisions. Moreover, cost accounting uses consistent historical data, ensuring that inventory values do not fluctuate wildly with temporary price changes.

This stability allows for more precise inventory planning and better decision-making. Retailers can track profit at the item level, enabling more effective delivery of business priorities. Profit tracking at this granular level helps in identifying which products are truly profitable versus those disguised by inflated retail prices. Additionally, cost accounting enhances the connection and agility among merchants, inventory planners, and other stakeholders by providing accurate and reliable data. This method supports better strategic decisions and operational efficiency, aligning seamlessly with modern technologies and data systems, which further underscores its superiority over the outdated RIM.

Transitioning from RIM to Cost Accounting

The transition from RIM to cost accounting is not without its challenges. For retailers like Nordstrom and Macy’s, this shift involves significant changes in their accounting practices and systems. However, the benefits of cost accounting far outweigh the transitional costs. Executives from both companies have highlighted the positive impact of the switch on various business decisions. Macy’s CFO Adrian Mitchell has emphasized how cost accounting has improved decision-making capabilities, while Nordstrom’s CFO Cathy Smith noted the method’s support for more effective profit tracking at the item level.

Mathematically, cost accounting provides a more stable and reliable measure of inventory values. By relying on consistent historical data, cost accounting eliminates the fluctuations caused by retail price changes. This stability is crucial for accurate financial reporting and strategic planning, marking a decisive improvement over the erratic nature of RIM. This reliable measure ensures that inventory valuations remain consistent, aiding in more precise financial forecasting and budgeting processes. In turn, this helps retailers avoid the pitfalls of inflated or deflated inventory values that can misguide financial statements and investment decisions.

Implications for Inventory Planning and Shrinkage

One of the significant implications of the shift to cost accounting is its impact on inventory planning. Under RIM, inventory values can be skewed by markdowns, leading to potentially misleading buying signals. This distortion can result in overstocking or understocking, which can harm sales and profit margins. Cost accounting, on the other hand, maintains constant inventory values, aiding in more precise inventory planning and buying decision accuracy. This constancy ensures that purchasing decisions are based on actual costs rather than fluctuating retail prices, thereby improving inventory turnover and return on investment.

Another critical area affected by the transition is the tracking of inventory shrinkage. RIM’s reliance on retail prices can create noise that complicates the identification of shrink causes. This can obscure essential details about where losses are occurring, be it through theft, damage, or administrative errors. Cost accounting improves operational capacity to address shrink issues by maintaining consistent inventory valuation. This accuracy is essential for identifying and addressing the root causes of inventory shrinkage, such as theft or loss. With clear, accurate data, retailers can implement more effective loss prevention strategies and improve overall inventory control.

Operational and Financial Reporting Impact

In a major development in the retail industry, Nordstrom and Macy’s, two of the largest U.S. retailers, have decided to replace the century-old retail inventory method (RIM) with cost accounting. This strategic transition signifies a crucial change in how these companies handle and report their inventory, aligning with broader industry trends and technological advancements.

The retail inventory method, established in the 1920s, has been widely used for its simplicity and ease of application. Over the years, RIM became a standard practice in the industry due to its straightforward approach to valuing inventory. However, the rapidly evolving retail environment has highlighted the drawbacks and obsolescence of this method. The outdated nature of RIM, coupled with the increased complexity and competition in retail, has prompted the shift to more precise and modern methods.

This article explores the rationale behind the shift, highlighting the advantages of cost accounting over RIM. Cost accounting offers a more accurate reflection of inventory costs and can improve financial reporting, boost efficiency, and better align with current technological capabilities. The implications for the retail sector are significant as companies seek to stay competitive and adapt to modern financial practices. Adopting cost accounting is expected to lead to enhanced inventory management and more informed decision-making processes, ultimately benefiting both retailers and their customers.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later